“Working” mom and “stay at home” mom – as useless as my land line?

I have no idea how I have been reading mom blogs for so long (the past 19 months counts as “so long” since it’s my little guy’s whole life) and haven’t before come across Mom-101.  One of my new favorites!  Awesome discussion over there of “doing it all” which prompted many comments, all fascinating and thoughtful.

It got me thinking again about one of the many false dichotomies in this parenting world – working moms and stay-at-home moms.

First, I think I have to untangle two issues if I’m going to make any sense to myself.  The first is whether there is or should be a war between these two groups (I’m going out on a limb and saying no).  Backing up, I do not personally believe there is much of a war between individual women, but people who want to sell newspapers and books want us to think there is.  My evidence – the 12 million results that come up in .9 seconds when you type “mommy wars” into Google.  More evidence that the war is not between individuals but is invented to sell books – even the author of the book “Mommy Wars” doesn’t fall neatly into one of the two categories (from her website: “the truth is I feel like a hybrid–neither working mom nor true stay-at-home mom.”).  Of course this did not stop her from sub-titling her book “Stay-at-home and career moms face off…”  Nuance, though tasty when paired with fine wine, does not sell books.

The competitive part of me wants to get a new team signed up for the league and start kicking ass!!  I even found an article suggesting that moms who work part time are a new “dominant power” in the “war between stay-at-home moms and full-time working moms.”  Heck yeah!  Where do I order my team shirt?!  We got next!

But even if we’re not doing battle (and really there are so many other awesome things to battle over), I think it’s also important to ask whether these two categories are even useful as descriptors – whether they tell us anything about people’s day to day lives (I’m becoming increasingly convinced that they don’t).

I realize that this point – that trying to force all moms into one of two categories fails to capture the breadth of the mom experience – is not revolutionary.  And I am certainly not against using categories, per se.  But these particular categories are used so much (insert ten day long link to all the articles on this issue) that it does seem it’s worth paying attention to whether we are getting our money’s worth from them.

The huge range of experiences of the people commenting on the Mom-101 post further convinced me that this is not a very useful way to break things down.  Arguably there is more difference between a mom who works 80 hours at a law firm/med student job (Mom A – not for type, but OK in some cases maybe a little for type), and a mom who works 30 hours a week, and sees her baby every lunch break (Mom B – not for grade, or cup size, or type of movie) than there is between Mom B and a mom who doesn’t work, but has a kid in preschool for a half day every day (Mom C).  Mom B and C might have a much more similar experience, yet Mom A and B would be lumped into “working moms” and Mom C would be a “stay at home” mom.   My own experience does not fit neatly into any category.  I was home for five months, then have been back at work part time (sneaking out to breastfeed my hardcore bottle refuser for the first few months back).   The comments also highlighted for me how these categories are not permanent traits for so many of us – so many of us go from one category to another (and then back again).  Makes trying to take sides in the “mommy wars” something like being a Brett Favre fan from 2007-2009.  You end up buying a lot of different jerseys and is it really worth the price.

Reading another Mom-101 post on this very issue made me also realize that probably a large part of why this “battle” rages on, is because it’s something we feel within ourselves.  We have some stake in watching the sides duke it out, hoping it will reveal some clues as to whether our particular combination of work and time with our children is the “right” one.  The sooner we stop judging ourselves, the sooner we can stop judging each other.  Free from the “wars” and the confines of the two made-up sides, perhaps then we can have real conversations about the challenges and decisions we all face.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to “Working” mom and “stay at home” mom – as useless as my land line?

  1. I don’t think it’s at all nice for moms to war against other moms – but frankly, like you, I don’t know that it’s happening on a macro level. I think it’s just little scuffles that happen now and then, like when I get miffed when someone calls being at work my break and how much easier I have it because I’m not at home (as if my house cleans itself and dinner is magically on the table when I get home and my daughter teaches herself her letters, etc.). That’s when I might get miffed and say something mean like “Gee, what do you do all day?” Which is all hypothetical, by the way. The only thing I’ve had said to me that really made me feel like I was in a war was when a SAHM mom accused me of not loving my child as much because I work.

    As if staying home and going broke and losing our house would somehow be a better proof of my love…

  2. Thanks for the comment! I agree, every time someone says something calling my choices into question, I want to throw some serious snark at them. It would feel so good. And usually I do in my head, and that helps 🙂 But then I guess that’s the point – we can’t let crap that is out there put us moms at war with each other, when really I don’t believe we are. Thanks for stopping by.

  3. I just came across your blog when my blog stats showed me that someone clicked through from your blog to mine. I love what I see and am disappointed to see that it looks like you stopped after four posts. If you do decide to get back into it, I’d love to read along.

    • phdinparenting – I am so incredibly honored you took the time to comment! I am a huge fan of your blog and find it to be one of the most interesting, balanced, and insightful blogs out there (hence the link to it!). Thank you so much for the encouragement. I have actually been really trying to figure out how to make time to write more here, so maybe this is all the prompting I need. We will see if my 6 week old and 3 year old agree 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s